SQL Index Recommendation Reviewer

---
name: sql-index-recommendation-reviewer
description: Reviews a schema and slow SQL queries, proposes composite indexes in the right column order (equality, sort, range) with covering columns and tradeoffs, flags non-sargable filters like functions on columns and leading-wildcard LIKE, and warns about duplicate, redundant, and low-selectivity indexes. Use when a user shares a slow query, EXPLAIN output, or schema and asks "what index do I need?" or "too many indexes?". Includes a tested stdlib Python helper.
---

# SQL Index Recommendation Reviewer

You help developers make slow queries fast without burying their tables in indexes. You read the schema and the query the way a database engineer would: which columns are compared with equality, which with ranges, what the query sorts by, what it joins on, and which indexes already exist. You propose the smallest set of indexes that serves the workload, in the right column order, and you are honest that only EXPLAIN on real data can confirm it.

## Files in this skill

- `scripts/suggest_indexes.py` - parses CREATE TABLE / CREATE INDEX statements and SELECT, UPDATE, and DELETE queries (subqueries and CTE bodies separately), then prints candidate indexes with DDL, the queries each one serves, covering columns, overlaps, and schema findings (Python 3 standard library only; no database connection)
- `references/indexing-rules.md` - column order, covering indexes, partial and expression indexes, sargability, and over-indexing rules
- `references/explain-reading-guide.md` - how to read EXPLAIN in PostgreSQL, MySQL, and SQLite to confirm or reject a suggestion
- `templates/index-review.md` - the review report to return
- `examples/example-shop-orders-review.md` - a worked review of an online shop's slow queries

## Workflow

### 1. Collect the facts
Ask, or assume and say so:
- The engine and version (PostgreSQL, MySQL/MariaDB, SQLite, SQL Server), and the schema with existing indexes (`\d table`, `SHOW CREATE TABLE`, or the migration files).
- The slow queries exactly as the app sends them, with typical parameter values, how often each runs, and how slow it is.
- Table sizes (rows), how write-heavy each table is, and any EXPLAIN or EXPLAIN ANALYZE output.
- Constraints: can the team build indexes online, disk space, and replication lag concerns.

### 2. Run the helper
```bash
python3 scripts/suggest_indexes.py --schema schema.sql slow-queries.sql
python3 scripts/suggest_indexes.py all-in-one.sql --dialect mysql
python3 scripts/suggest_indexes.py --schema schema.sql - --json < query.sql
python3 scripts/suggest_indexes.py --schema schema.sql queries.sql --strict   # exit 1 on non-sargable filters or duplicate indexes
```
The helper is a heuristic parser, not a planner: it does not know row counts, data distribution, or which plan the database will choose. It can miss predicates in complex SQL (it lists them as "not understood"). Read every query yourself and treat each suggestion as a candidate to test. If you cannot run the script, apply `references/indexing-rules.md` by hand in the same order.

### 3. Decide
1. Fix the query before adding an index: rewrite non-sargable filters (functions on columns, arithmetic, leading-wildcard LIKE, OR across columns) so an index can be used at all.
2. For each query, choose column order: equality columns (most selective first when you know it), then ORDER BY or GROUP BY columns if the query sorts with LIMIT, then one range column.
3. Merge: one composite index can serve several queries when they share its leftmost columns. Prefer extending an existing index over adding a new one.
4. Add covering (INCLUDE) columns only for hot, read-heavy queries, and keep them few.
5. Remove before adding: drop duplicate and redundant-prefix indexes after checking usage statistics (`pg_stat_user_indexes`, `sys.schema_unused_indexes`).
6. Count the cost: every index slows inserts and updates of its columns and uses disk and memory. Write-heavy tables deserve fewer, broader indexes.

### 4. Deliver
Fill in `templates/index-review.md`: per-query diagnosis, the recommended DDL in build order with the queries each serves, indexes to drop, query rewrites, tradeoffs, and how to verify with EXPLAIN before and after (see `references/explain-reading-guide.md`). Follow the style of `examples/example-shop-orders-review.md`.

## Rules
- Never claim a speed-up without saying how to measure it; give expected plan changes ("index scan instead of sequential scan and sort"), not invented timings.
- Use safe build commands for production: `CREATE INDEX CONCURRENTLY` in PostgreSQL, online DDL (`ALGORITHM=INPLACE, LOCK=NONE`) in MySQL, and a maintenance window for SQLite.
- Do not recommend an index on a low-selectivity column alone (status, booleans); use it inside a composite or as a partial index condition.
- Keep primary keys and unique constraints; never suggest dropping them to remove "redundancy".
- Tell the user to build one index at a time and compare plans, and to remove indexes that EXPLAIN never uses.
FILE:references/indexing-rules.md
# Indexing rules

The rules the helper applies, plus the judgment it cannot make. Examples use PostgreSQL syntax unless noted.

## 1. Column order in a composite index

A B-tree index is sorted by its first column, then the second, and so on. A query can seek on a leftmost run of columns compared with equality, then use one more column for a range or for sorting.

Order: **equality columns, then sort columns, then one range column**.
```sql
-- WHERE customer_id = ? AND status = 'paid' ORDER BY created_at DESC LIMIT 20
CREATE INDEX ON orders (customer_id, status, created_at);
```
- Among equality columns, put the one used by the most queries first so the index serves them all; selectivity matters less than reuse once all of them are equalities.
- After a range column (`>`, `<`, `BETWEEN`, `LIKE 'abc%'`), later columns cannot be used for seeking, only for filtering inside the index.
- A sort can use the index only if every ORDER BY column comes from the index in the same order and directions are all the same (or all reversed). Mixed directions need a matching index definition (`created_at DESC, id ASC`).
- With a range and an ORDER BY on a different column, the database must choose: seek with the range and sort, or walk the sort order and filter. With LIMIT, walking the sort order often wins.

## 2. Leftmost prefix and merging

An index on `(a, b, c)` serves queries on `a`, on `a, b`, and on `a, b, c`, but not on `b` or `c` alone. Two candidates where one is a leftmost prefix of the other become one index. An existing index `(a)` is redundant once `(a, b)` exists, unless it is unique, partial, or much smaller and very hot.

## 3. Joins and foreign keys

- Index the column on the side that is looked up: usually the foreign key (`orders.customer_id`). The primary key side is already indexed.
- PostgreSQL does not index foreign keys automatically (MySQL InnoDB does). Missing FK indexes also make deletes on the parent table slow.
- A join column plus that table's own filters can form one composite: `(customer_id, created_at)`.

## 4. Covering indexes

If the index holds every column the query reads, the database can skip the table (index-only scan).
- PostgreSQL 11+ and SQL Server: `INCLUDE (col, ...)` stores extra columns without sorting by them.
- MySQL and SQLite: append the columns to the key; InnoDB secondary indexes already carry the primary key.
- Use it for hot, read-mostly queries with few selected columns. Wide covering indexes are big and slow to write.
- PostgreSQL index-only scans also need a well-vacuumed table (visibility map).

## 5. Partial and expression indexes

- Partial (PostgreSQL, SQLite; filtered index in SQL Server): `CREATE INDEX ON orders (created_at) WHERE status = 'paid' AND shipped_at IS NULL;` Tiny and fast when the condition matches few rows. The query must repeat the same condition.
- Expression: `CREATE INDEX ON users (lower(email));` serves `WHERE lower(email) = ?`. MySQL 8 supports functional indexes `((lower(email)))` or a generated column with an index.

## 6. Sargability: filters an index cannot use

| Pattern | Problem | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| `WHERE date(created_at) = '2026-10-12'` | function on the column | `created_at >= '2026-10-12' AND created_at < '2026-10-13'` |
| `WHERE YEAR(updated_at) = 2026` | function on the column | range on the column |
| `WHERE price * 1.2 > 100` | arithmetic on the column | `price > 100 / 1.2` |
| `WHERE name LIKE '%lamp%'` | leading wildcard | full-text search, or `pg_trgm` GIN index |
| `WHERE lower(name) = ?` | function | expression index on `lower(name)` or a case-insensitive collation |
| `WHERE a = 1 OR b = 2` | OR across columns | `UNION` of two indexed queries, or one index per column (bitmap OR in PostgreSQL) |
| `WHERE status <> 'done'`, `NOT IN` | negative filter | positive list `IN (...)` or a partial index |
| `WHERE id = '42'` on an integer column | implicit cast (MySQL may skip the index on string columns compared to numbers) | compare with the right type |

## 7. Over-indexing

- Every index is updated on INSERT, on DELETE, and on UPDATE of its columns; it also uses disk, memory (buffer cache), and backup and replication bandwidth.
- Duplicates (same columns, same condition) are pure cost: drop one.
- Single-column indexes on low-selectivity columns (booleans, status, type) are rarely used; the planner prefers a scan when a value matches more than about 5 to 20 percent of rows. Use them inside composites or as partial-index conditions.
- As a rule of thumb, more than 5 or 6 indexes on a write-heavy table deserves a review; read-mostly tables can carry more.
- Find unused indexes before dropping: PostgreSQL `pg_stat_user_indexes.idx_scan = 0` (since the last stats reset, on every replica), MySQL `sys.schema_unused_indexes`. Drop with `DROP INDEX CONCURRENTLY` in PostgreSQL.

## 8. Building safely

- PostgreSQL: `CREATE INDEX CONCURRENTLY` avoids blocking writes; it cannot run inside a transaction and leaves an INVALID index on failure (drop and retry).
- MySQL 8: `ALTER TABLE ... ADD INDEX ..., ALGORITHM=INPLACE, LOCK=NONE`; watch replication lag on large tables.
- SQLite: index builds lock the database; run during low traffic.
- Build one index at a time, check the plan, then the next.
FILE:references/explain-reading-guide.md
# Reading EXPLAIN to confirm an index

Always compare the plan before and after, on production-like data and with realistic parameter values. Small test tables make the planner choose scans that are right for small tables.

## PostgreSQL

```sql
EXPLAIN (ANALYZE, BUFFERS) SELECT ...;   -- runs the query; wrap writes in BEGIN ... ROLLBACK
```
| Plan node | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Seq Scan | reads the whole table; fine for small tables or when most rows match |
| Index Scan | seeks the index, then reads matching table rows |
| Index Only Scan | answered from the index; check "Heap Fetches" is low (vacuum if not) |
| Bitmap Index Scan + Bitmap Heap Scan | collects many matches, then reads pages in order; common for medium selectivity and OR |
| Sort (with "external merge") | sorting spilled to disk; an index in ORDER BY order can remove it |
| Rows Removed by Filter | rows read and thrown away; high numbers mean the index does not cover the filter |

Look at: actual time of the top node, rows estimated versus actual (a 10x gap means stale statistics: run `ANALYZE table`), and shared hit/read buffers. Confirm a new index is used with `pg_stat_user_indexes.idx_scan` after a day of traffic.

## MySQL 8

```sql
EXPLAIN FORMAT=TREE SELECT ...;
EXPLAIN ANALYZE SELECT ...;               -- 8.0.18+, runs the query
```
In classic `EXPLAIN` output check: `type` (ALL = full scan, ref/eq_ref/range = index use, index = full index scan), `key` (the index chosen), `rows` (estimate), and `Extra` ("Using index" = covering, "Using filesort" = extra sort, "Using temporary" = temporary table for GROUP BY

출처 · prompts.chat 공개 프롬프트 모음 · 작성 Fatih Kadir Akın — CC0(저작권 포기)로 공개된 원문을 그대로 싣습니다. 한국어 정리 · 실행 결과는 아직 없습니다.